Every budget traveler faces this classic dilemma: backpack or suitcase?
It might sound like a simple preference, but your luggage choice can have a big impact on how smoothly (or not) your trip goes—especially when you’re navigating train platforms, hostel staircases, or cobbled streets in southern Europe.
If you’re trying to decide between a suitcase or a backpack for your next trip, here’s what to consider based on actual travel experience—not just internet opinions.
Disclosure: This page contains affiliate links. If you purchase through these links, I may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. Thank you for supporting CheapWanderlust!
Why Some Travelers Swear by Backpacks
Backpacks are the go-to choice for many long-term or budget travelers, and it’s easy to see why.
Pros:
Hands-free movement: Perfect for buses, metro stations, and crowded places where rolling luggage is awkward.
Better on uneven terrain: Cobblestones in Spain, hostel stairs in Lisbon, or unpaved roads in the Balkans? Backpacks win.
More flexible: You can squish a backpack into an overhead bin or under a hostel bed more easily than a hard-shell suitcase.
Cons:
Can get uncomfortable: If it doesn’t fit well or you overpack, it’s a strain on your back and shoulders.
Messier packing: Unless you use cubes or pouches, it can feel like you’re digging through layers just to find clean socks.
Not ideal for fragile items: Electronics, wine bottles, or souvenirs? Pack them carefully or leave them behind.
Need help picking the right one?
Check out our guide: Top Travel Backpacks for Under $200
The Case for Suitcases (Even on a Budget)
Suitcases get a bad rap in the budget travel world, but they have their place—especially for travelers who value structure, comfort, or organization.
Pros:
No heavy lifting: Roll it instead of carrying it. Great if you have mobility issues or prefer to avoid back strain.
Structured organization: Easy to pack and access everything at a glance—especially if you like folding rather than stuffing.
Great for city travel: If you’re staying in hostels or hotels near transit, wheels make moving around easier.
Cons:
Terrible on rough terrain: Cobblestones, stairs, dirt roads? Not suitcase-friendly.
More fragile: Cheap wheels break easily, zippers snap, and cracks happen.
Harder to store: Bulky and often too rigid for minimalist setups.
Looking for a budget-friendly suitcase that still performs?
Here’s a great option:
Check it out on Amazon
Is There a Middle Ground?
Yes—hybrids exist.
Some brands offer travel backpacks with wheels, or duffel-style carry-ons with backpack straps. These are ideal for people doing a mix of travel styles: hostels + cities + side trips off the beaten path.
They’re usually carry-on sized, flexible, and give you the best of both worlds. Not always perfect, but good for those who don’t want to commit 100% to one style.
Here’s one with both wheels and straps:
Check it out on Amazon
So… What’s Best for You?
Here’s a quick way to decide:
Staying mostly in cities or hostels with elevators? A suitcase might make more sense.
Taking trains, buses, or budget flights often? Go for a backpack.
Traveling in winter or with bulky gear? Backpack gives you more flexibility.
Need easy access to clothes for short trips? Suitcase might feel more efficient.
If you can comfortably carry 7–10kg on your back, a travel backpack is often the best all-around choice for budget travelers.
Final Thoughts
There’s no one-size-fits-all answer. Some people are forever team backpack. Others wouldn’t touch one with a ten-foot pole.
But if you’re on a budget, taking local transport, and staying in hostels or Airbnbs, a well-fitted backpack is usually your best bet—especially when paired with packing cubes and a minimalist mindset.
Already decided?
Fill your bag with gear that’s lightweight and actually useful:
15 Travel Accessories Under €25 That Are Actually Worth Packing
Or build your packing strategy around a 7kg carry-on:
Read: The Ultimate Packing List for Europe (Under 7kg)